Continuing the theme of IELTS lessons, this is another that looks to help students with their exam but also their university studies after.
This looks to explore what arguments are being made and then asks students to respond to them. Stance and criticality are key elements of university study. The ability to understand a writer’s ideas and then use them in their own writing will be tested but sometimes perhaps gets lost in the IELTS classroom. This is a lesson which will work a little on reading skills, but which mostly seeks to prepare students for university. That in turn makes it suitable for any high-level class.
Of course, you can, and should, do all the other lovely textploitation things with a grammar and lexis focus.
Level: IELTS / Advanced / Proficiency
Aim: To give students an opportunity to examine a writer’s opinion and respond to it.
Reading Skills – Prediction
- Direct Students to the worksheet and put them in pairs to discuss what the terms could mean. Focus students on the form of the words. Remember to stress the importance of prediction as a reading skill.
- Read to check – Now ask the students to read the text and find out what the two terms mean. Ask the students which reading techniques they will use: ‘Scanning’ to find the terms and then ‘deeper reading’ to understand.
- To check understanding and practice paraphrasing, ask the students to write their own definitions. Encourage them to think of synonyms and to use different grammar structures. This might be a time to bring in the idea of plagiarism if they haven’t discussed it before. Below are the sections of the text that would need to be paraphrased:
Universal Basic Income (UBI) is a policy whereby a financial payment is made to every citizen, unconditionally, without any obligation to work, at a level above their subsistence needs.
Half-Earth – the simple but profound idea that environmental repair could come from allocating half the Earth’s surface primarily for the benefit of other species
Reading – Note-taking
- This skill will help with IELTS tasks such as matching, but it is a skill I encourage all of my students to do every time they read an exam text. Ask the students to skim read the text – set a time limit (5mins) – encourage them to take notes in the margins.
- Now ask them to compare their notes to their classmates. Make your own notes and see how similar your students are.
NB The article roughly fits a situation / problem / solutions / questioning solutions and conclusion structure.
Reading – Stance and argument
- Ask the students to reread the text and look for the writer’s opinions. Then follow the instructions on the worksheet.
Answers: People would still work; break link between work and consumption; ability to say no to undesirable jobs; chance to think long-term
Answers: Reforesting already in action / our views on nature are forged by our society / re-establishing humans as part of nature / seems popular
note taking on different sections – explain how it helps with matching
Ask students to work in pairs or small groups and discuss the points on the worksheet.
Writing: summary and reacting to it in an academic style to be set as homework.
When marking, encourage students for their content, don’t just mark the grammar and the vocab. Look at the structure, arguments and how they are supported and their paraphrasing / summarising skills.
Original article taken from: https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2018/jun/12/universal-basic-income-and-rewilding-can-meet-anthropocene-demands